Some people love buying new. They want to be the first person to sleep in the bed, use the kitchen and put their belongings in the cupboards.
I understand that. There’s something special about owning something nobody else has used.
But does brand new always mean the best holiday home for your money? In my experience, you should always look at both options before deciding.
Think Fiat Punto versus Mercedes-Benz CLA
Imagine choosing between a brand-new Fiat Punto and a well-kept, pre-owned Mercedes-Benz CLA.
The Fiat has the latest registration plate. It’s shiny, unused and comes with the reassurance of a manufacturer’s warranty.
But sit inside the Mercedes. Depending on its specification, you could have better-quality upholstery, more equipment and a finish that feels noticeably more luxurious. You might simply prefer its looks and the experience of being in it.
The newer car won’t necessarily be the one you enjoy most.
Holiday homes can present exactly that choice. Your budget might buy a basic new model or a higher-specification pre-owned home with more of the features and comfort you actually want.
That doesn’t make every pre-owned lodge a bargain. Condition, specification and price still matter. But choosing purely because something is new could mean overlooking a home you would prefer.
A real example: two Vendees at Croft Lakes
We currently have two Swift Vendee lodges at Croft Lakes. This comparison is slightly different from the car example because both have the same specification.
One is a pre-owned 2025 model at £79,997. The other is a brand-new 2027 model at £87,997.
So what does the £8,000 difference buy you?
| Feature | Pre-owned 2025 Vendee | Brand-new 2027 Vendee |
|---|---|---|
| Price | £79,997 | £87,997 |
| Setting | Established, south-facing lakeside plot | New development |
| Decking | Large deck and skirting included | Decking included |
| Shed | Included | Not included in this comparison |
| Condition | Immaculate, with very little sign of use | Brand new |
| Warranty | Six-month MLH warranty | Swift manufacturer warranty package |
| 2027 site fees | Included | Included |
Croft Lakes has a 12-month holiday season, and the annual site fee is £2,950. Both packages include the 2027 site fees.
Which one would I buy?
Personally, I would take the pre-owned lodge.
The setting is a big part of that decision. It has a lovely south-facing plot beside a mature lake, a large deck and an included shed. The surrounding holiday homes are already there, so you can see your neighbours and get a feel for the area.
Inside, it’s immaculate. There’s very little sign of use, the layout is the same as the new model and the décor hasn’t changed dramatically.
Once our checks, testing and preparation are complete, you could start enjoying it relatively quickly.
The new Vendee is the third lodge on its development. Some buyers will like being among the first owners there. Others will prefer established planting, occupied neighbouring plots and surroundings that have already matured.
For me, the pre-owned lodge offers the setting I prefer while leaving £8,000 in my pocket.
That is my personal choice. Yours might be different.
Why would someone spend the extra on new?
Because being the first owner matters to them—and that is a valid preference.
Everything is unused. There are no alterations made to another owner’s taste, and you have the manufacturer’s warranty package.
Swift offers a three-year manufacturer’s warranty, a five-year structural warranty and a ten-year chassis warranty. Each provides a different level of cover, subject to Swift’s terms and conditions.
In our Vendee comparison, the extra money buys a brand-new home and that manufacturer warranty package, on a different part of the park. It doesn’t buy a higher specification.
The question is whether those benefits are worth £8,000 to you.
What can make pre-owned such good value?
A well-chosen pre-owned home can come with a substantial amount already in place.
Decking, skirting, a shed and additional furniture can make the package more attractive. An established pitch also lets you assess the actual outlook, privacy and outdoor space before committing.
The original owner paid the original retail package price, including whatever delivery, siting and installation arrangements applied.
However, I wouldn’t tell you that previously paid costs automatically make something good value. Compare what you will pay now, what is included and what you might need to spend afterwards.
A higher-specification pre-owned lodge could give you the kitchen, bathroom, furniture and space you would have to compromise on when buying new at the same budget.
How we prepare our pre-owned homes
We’ve been doing this for years. We know the common defects and where to look for problems before buying stock or accepting a part exchange.
Our process includes a 30-point check. Every holiday home we sell is also gas tested, electrically tested and cleaned before handover.
Our standard pre-owned warranty lasts six months and covers areas including appliances, leaks, structural integrity, electrics, plumbing, windows and doors, subject to its written terms.
It makes no sense for us to buy a holiday home that isn’t up to standard and then take responsibility for providing a warranty on it.
Can something occasionally slip through? Yes. We won’t pretend any inspection makes that impossible. If a covered fault emerges, we aim to put it right promptly.
Where we know about a defect, our approach is to explain it and reflect it in the price. We don’t try to hide it.
What are the compromises with pre-owned?
Someone else has chosen the pitch, furnishings and any modifications. Those choices might suit you perfectly—or leave you wanting to make changes.
You also need to consider:
- Wear and maintenance: check the home’s condition and history, including decking and other extras.
- Warranty: establish exactly what cover comes with the sale.
- Pitch agreement: check its start date, remaining term and renewal arrangements.
- Finance: the age of the home may affect the repayment term available.
- Specification: a premium name alone doesn’t establish insulation levels, equipment or suitability for your intended use.
These are reasons to ask questions and compare carefully.
My advice: buy the home you’ll enjoy owning
Don’t dismiss pre-owned because someone else has used it. Equally, don’t buy it simply because it costs less.
View both options. Sit on the sofas, look inside the cupboards, walk around the decking and spend a little time taking in the surroundings.
Compare the complete package: home, condition, specification, pitch, warranty and price.
And remember that ongoing costs continue whichever you choose. Allow for site fees, utilities, insurance and maintenance. A 12-month holiday season also remains holiday use, rather than permission to live there permanently.
For the two Vendees at Croft Lakes, I would choose the pre-owned lodge. Another customer may happily pay more to be the first owner of the new one.
Our job is to help you understand the difference so you can make the choice that suits you.
Want to compare new and pre-owned holiday homes? Tell us your budget and what matters most, and we’ll talk you through the options honestly.
Stock and package details correct at the time of writing in November 2026. Confirm availability, inclusions, warranty terms and the park agreement before purchase.
Further reading
The manufacturer's own page for the Vendee lodge.
